27.03.2023
Zeitschriftenartikel

Transformative Constitutionalism in Luxembourg: How the Court Can Support Democratic Transitions

For more than a decade, the illiberal developments in Hungary and Poland pose an ever-growing challenge to the European Union and the very idea of liberal democracy. Though the European legislature has eventually adopted the rule of law conditionality regulation, the political processes seem hardly capable of meeting the challenge alone. So again, the Court of Justice has stood up for the European integration agenda – this time by mobilizing the Union’s common values. Pushed by the developments in Poland and Hungary, the Court’s jurisprudence has evolved with unprecedented speed.
We suggest reframing this jurisprudence as an expression of transformative constitutionalism. At its heart, this concept addresses the question of how constitutional adjudication can propel societal transformation (Section I). What is the added value of such a framing? First, it provides a better understanding of the problem. There is no quick fix for Hungary and Poland. Even if the respective governments change, it will take time, effort and support to overcome entrenched, systemic deficiencies and restore democracy. Transformative constitutionalism sheds a light on such processes and provides insights from other jurisdictions facing similar challenges. Second, the concept may justify a court’s active involvement in such transformative processes. The CJEU’s interventions are criticized as yet another power-grab from Luxembourg, not only by recalcitrant Member State governments, but also by constitutional courts and scholars. Framing the decisions in terms of transformative constitutionalism provides a constructive attitude towards court-driven transformations.
Liberal democracy cannot be externally imposed. Ultimately, it must emerge from within a society, especially by electing a new government. However, external forces can support such processes. Against this backdrop, we will demonstrate how the CJEU has mobilized the Union’s values and assess the grounds that justify this extensive interpretation of its mandate (Section II). We then develop the potential of this jurisprudence for democratic transitions (Section III). Over the past years, the Court has focused on defending European values in reaction to illiberal challenges in the Member States. We suggest expanding the Court’s horizon by taking a more forward-looking perspective. Judicial decisions can support democratic transitions both before and after elections. Before election day, the Court can aim at safeguarding the preconditions for democratic processes. Once elections have taken place, it can support new governments in restoring their legal systems in line with the Union’s common values.

Neuigkeiten aus dem Forschungsinstitut

Veranstaltung
16.06.2025 | Frankfurt am Main

Trump and the Assault on the State

Vortrag

Vortrag von Jeffrey Kopstein Professor der Politikwissenschaft an der University of California, Irvine) über die Gefahr einer Erosion des Staates und Wege gegen den Trend zur Zerstörung.

weitere Infos ›
News
19.05.2025

Was kann eine barocke Tapisserie über koloniale Ikonographie erzählen?

Vortrag von Cécile Fromone am 21. Mai. Die Professorin am Department of the History of Art and Architecture der Harvard University sowie Direktorin der Cooper Gallery am Hutchins Center und Autorin wird über lange vergessene afrikanische Ursprünge der Ikonographie und deren koloniale Dimension referieren.

weitere Infos ›
Veranstaltung
10.06.2025 | Frankfurt am Main

Polizeipraxis zwischen staatlichem Auftrag und öffentlicher Kritik.

Ringvorlesungen

Vortrag von Astrid Jacobsen (IKRIS / Polizeiakademie Niedersachsen) über Herausforderungen, Bewältigungsstrategien und Risikokonstellationen im Kontext von polizeilichem Rassismus

weitere Infos ›
News
05.05.2025

Normative Orders Newsletter 01/25 erschienen

Der Newsletter aus dem Forschungszentrum Normative Ordnungen versammelt mehrmals im Jahr Informationen über aktuelle Veranstaltungen, Berichte, Neuigkeiten und Veröffentlichungen. Lesen Sie hier die erste Ausgabe 2025.

weitere Infos ›
News
05.05.2025

„Hitler. Geschichte eines Diktators“ von Sybille Steinbacher erscheint am 15. Mai 2025

Das Buch neue der Historikerin befasst sich mit Hitlers Herkunft, den Wurzeln seines Antisemitismus sowie seinem Aufstieg.

weitere Infos ›
News
29.04.2025

Öffentliche Ringvorlesung „Rassismus in der Polizei“ beginnt am 13. Mai 2025

Rassismus in der Polizei hat verschiedene Dimensionen. In der Ringvorlesung „Rassismus in der Polizei – Empirische Befunde, methodische Herangehensweisen und Kontroversen“ werden drei empirische Studien zur Polizeiarbeit vorgestellt.

weitere Infos ›
Publikation
22.04.2025 | Lexikoneintrag

Edessa (Fourth Century bc to the Eighth Century ad)

Leppin, Hartmut (2025): "Edessa (Fourth Century bc to the Eighth Century ad)". In: Raja, Rubina (Hrsg.): The Oxford Handbook of the Hellenistic and Roman Near East, Oxford Academic, S. 491-506.

weitere Infos ›
News
10.04.2025

Zukunft gestalten – Zwischen Klimawandel, Technologie und gesellschaftlicher Verantwortung

Eine neue Vortragsreihe des Forschungszentrums im Rahmen der Ausstellung „Fixing Futures“ über Implikationen des Klimawandels und technologischen Fortschritts.

weitere Infos ›
This site is registered on wpml.org as a development site.