The limits of helping under conditions of multiple crises

The aim is to explore the symbolic boundaries of helping. These are determined on three levels: At the micro level, in the everyday interaction of practices of helping and their justifications; at the meso level, in the way individual practices of helping are interlinked with state agencies – especially local government; and at the macro level, in the way discourses of helping mediated by the mass media are reflected in the symbolic demarcations of actors from different social milieus. These objectives will be addressed in three sub-projects – corresponding to these levels – based on the analysis of individual and expert interviews, group discussions and media discourses. Firstly, the way in which volunteers and refugees in rural areas reflect on and evaluate their practices of helping and the relationships that have emerged from them will be examined. Many of these helping relationships have existed since 2015 and are characterized by a surprising durability. Other helping relationships have emerged since the arrival of Ukrainian women in 2022. The sub-project focuses on how the actors involved engage with this everyday aid and the boundaries they mark in their practices. Secondly, it examines the way in which local authorities and volunteers interact in supporting refugees. The sub-project will answer the questions of where local authorities mark the boundaries of voluntary help and insist on state responsibilities, where they replace their own responsibilities with voluntary work and how conflicts between volunteers and municipal employees are handled and resolved. Thirdly, it examines the way in which justifications of helping and its limits are discursively produced and how these are conveyed to ordinary actors from different contexts and milieus. Under the conditions of the high frequency of global crises in recent years, it can be assumed that actors are increasingly grappling with their own dependency and vulnerability. The aim of the sub-project is to reconstruct the (exclusive) solidarities that emerge under these conditions and to examine the way in which they are reflected in justifications of helping and their limits in different social milieus. The research findings, which will also be made available to the wider public via events, podcasts and publications, are intended to promote public debate about the limits of helping and their justifications. In concrete terms, both volunteers who are involved in helping others and public administrations that coordinate their measures with volunteers can benefit from the research group’s findings.

Responsible for the project: Prof. Dr. Greta Wagner

The project is funded by the German Research Foundation (DFG)

News from the research center

Event
15.10.2025 | Frankfurt am Main

Aufrecht. Überleben im Zeitalter der Extreme

Book Presentation

In ihrem jüngsten Werk begibt sich Lea Ypi auf eine Reise in die Vergangenheit ihrer Familie und verknüpft persönliche Erinnerungen mit den großen politischen und gesellschaftlichen Umbrüchen des 20. Jahrhunderts. Das Forschungszentrum Normative Ordnungen lädt gemeinsam mit dem Netzwerk FrauenmitFormat, dem Honorarkonsulat der Republik Albanien in Frankfurt am Main und dem Suhrkamp Verlag herzlich zur Vorstellung des neuen Buches von Prof. Dr. Lea Ypi mit anschließender Diskussionsrunde mit Prof. Dr. Lea Ypi, Honorarkonsulin Dr. Jonela Hoxhaj und Prof. Dr. Rainer Forst unter der Moderation von Rebecca C. Schmidt ein.

more information ›
Publication
02.09.2025 | Journal article

Beyond Myth Busting: How Engagement with Ethical Dilemmas Can Improve Debates and Policymaking on Migration

Schmid, Lukas; Ruhs, Martin; Bauböck, Rainer; Mourão Permoser, Julia (2025): "Beyond Myth Busting: How Engagement with Ethical Dilemmas Can Improve Debates and Policymaking on Migration". In: Ethics & International Affairs, 39 (1), S. 26-36.

more information ›
Publication
01.09.2025 | Journal article

Roundtable: Ethical Dilemmas and Migration Policymaking

Schmid, Lukas; Ruhs, Martin; Bauböck Rainer, Mourão Permoser, Julia (Hrsg.) (2025): "Roundtable: Ethical Dilemmas and Migration Policymaking". In: Ethics & International Affairs, 39 (1)

more information ›
Event
17.09.2025 | Frankfurt am Main

Frieden retten! Friedensgutachten 2025

Book Presentation

Der Frieden ist auf dem Rückzug: Russlands Krieg in der Ukraine destabilisiert Europa, der Krieg in Gaza stürzt den Nahen Osten in Leid und Gewalt, und im Sudan hat der Konflikt die größte humanitäre Katastrophe der Welt ausgelöst. Zugleich fällt der globale Stabilitätsanker USA aus. Das Friedensgutachten 2025 zeigt, warum Europa selbst für seine Sicherheit und Verteidigung sorgen und zugleich am Ziel des Friedens festhalten muss.

more information ›
News
31.07.2025

Shaping the future - a review

As part of the exhibition "Fixing Futures. Planetary futures between speculation and control", our four-part lecture series "Shaping the future - between climate change, technology and social responsibility" took place.

more information ›
News
30.07.2025

What remains of "1968" - event review

What can we learn from the 1968 movement for our own time and where do we perhaps need new ideas and utopias? The event "Utopia and awakening of the 1968ers - What remains of political rebellion and individual self-liberation" on July 14, 2025 at the Historisches Museum was dedicated to these questions

more information ›
News
10.07.2025

Impressions from the Crisis Talk "Europe in a multipolar world"

The Crisis Talk "Europe in a multipolar world - How can the EU meet the challenges of major powers?" held on July 1, 2025 at the Representation of the State of Hesse to the European Union was dedicated to the question of how the EU should shape its influence and assume its responsibilities in this international environment.

more information ›
News
08.07.2025

Reflections on the defense of democracy - Two crises of democracy

The challenges are global, but we still act nationally. In addition, we lack the terms to orient ourselves politically and normatively. An article by Rainer Forst in the FR about the two crises of democracy.

more information ›
News
01.07.2025

How the erosion of modern governments threatens our future - Impressions from Jeffrey Kopstein's lecture

On June 16, Jeffrey Kopstein, Professor of Political Science at the University of California, Irvine, gave a public lecture entitled "Trump and the Assault on the State" at the Research Centre Normative Orders. The starting point of his presentation was the observation that attacks on modern statehood are increasing in many countries: Politicians are coming to power who deliberately want to weaken or even destroy central institutions.

more information ›